French say "Non!"
OK, I will admit up front that I don't understand all of the ins and out of the European Union, so especially to my friends in Europe, please forgive me. Nevertheless, the overwhelming vote in France against the proposed EU Constitution is big news, not only for other European nations, but for the U.S. as well.
Many of the problems that have developed between some European nations and the U.S. over the past several years have come from leaders of "Old Europe" nations like France, Germany, Belgium, etc., while a great deal of support and true alliances have been demonstrated by countries such as those
in the Baltic States. The vote yesterday is a huge blow to many of the leaders in Old Europe, especially French President, Jacques Chirac, who more or less staked his presidency on this issue. Clearly, he understood his unpopularity as the president of a country with unemployment at a five year high of over 10 percent when he urged the people not to make the vote a referendum on his government. What a leader! "Yes, I know that I'm a lousy president. I know that you all hate me and that I have run this country into the ground, but that's not what this is about...so just do what I tell you to do. Trust me on this." Uh, sure.
It appears the French didn't buy it, shocking as that may be based on some of the other stuff they've bought into, and that is exactly what happened. To make matters even better, following this defeat, calls for Chirac's resignation were issued. Of course, no strong Frenchman like Chirac would ever retreat or face defeat; never cower in the face of danger, political or otherwise (OK, well, forget about World War II...and the Iraqi war...and...alright, never mind, I can't even say that with a straight face). Suffice it to say, there is too much arrogance on the part of Chirac to ever resign in the face of such humiliation. Instead, he'll probably stand like his "great" predecessor, Charles De Gaul, who had the nerve to stand before his people and give credit to the French troops for their great victory and the defense of France against Germany in World War II
without so much as a "thank you" to those who prevented them from having to learn German, and declare some sort of delusional victory. As Reuters points out, "In a turnout of 69.7 percent, many voters used the vote to punish Chirac and his government over France's economy and high unemployment. The 72-year-old leader promised to make changes but ignored calls from some in the "No" camp to step down." Surprise, surprise.
For some, the defeat of the constitution in France is great news for Democracy in general and European democracy, in particular. In the Weekly Standard, Bill Kristol claims that this defeat offers opportunity for the proponents of democratic progress in Europe to stand up and make a difference, similar to the conservative overhaul in the recent American elections:
Ironically, it is this socialism that many in France seem to be fighting to hold onto by issuing a no vote. Will a rejection of the EU constitution provide an opportunity for true democracy, free markets, new opportunities in European/American relations like Kristol optimistically hopes for? One can certainly hope so, yet it seems that the very reason many French citizens voted against the constitution was that it seemed to threaten their socialist ways as well as their sovereignty as a nation. It appears that these citizens want to see an increase in the socialism that already defines the country. Why would they possibly want to hold onto such weak structure? Perhaps one answer is that it is simply all they have ever known. As C.S. Lewis' said, "We are half-hearted creatures...like an ignorant child who wants to go on making mudpies in the slums because he cannot imagine what is meant by the offer of a holiday at the sea."
As a young boy, my mother often had to threaten to separate my friend and I when we would misbehave at inappropriate times. It was the first step in her regaining control and peace. One can hope that this type of move towards an effective Europe is what is happening. Perhaps we are witnessing a separation of old, obstructionist allies: "'This is the first time in 50 years that the French and Germans have diverged in Europe on a fundamental issue. Without this constitution, Europe is broken down politically,' said foreign minister Michel Barnier." [source: EUpolitix.com]
It is my hope and prayer that this "non" vote may provide opportunity for improvements to the European Union. I pray that more reasonable and noble voices will emerge to offer a more hopeful alternative for the people of Europe.
Update: For excellent and insightful commentary on the subject, check out today´s post by my friend, Peter Glover.
Many of the problems that have developed between some European nations and the U.S. over the past several years have come from leaders of "Old Europe" nations like France, Germany, Belgium, etc., while a great deal of support and true alliances have been demonstrated by countries such as those
in the Baltic States. The vote yesterday is a huge blow to many of the leaders in Old Europe, especially French President, Jacques Chirac, who more or less staked his presidency on this issue. Clearly, he understood his unpopularity as the president of a country with unemployment at a five year high of over 10 percent when he urged the people not to make the vote a referendum on his government. What a leader! "Yes, I know that I'm a lousy president. I know that you all hate me and that I have run this country into the ground, but that's not what this is about...so just do what I tell you to do. Trust me on this." Uh, sure.It appears the French didn't buy it, shocking as that may be based on some of the other stuff they've bought into, and that is exactly what happened. To make matters even better, following this defeat, calls for Chirac's resignation were issued. Of course, no strong Frenchman like Chirac would ever retreat or face defeat; never cower in the face of danger, political or otherwise (OK, well, forget about World War II...and the Iraqi war...and...alright, never mind, I can't even say that with a straight face). Suffice it to say, there is too much arrogance on the part of Chirac to ever resign in the face of such humiliation. Instead, he'll probably stand like his "great" predecessor, Charles De Gaul, who had the nerve to stand before his people and give credit to the French troops for their great victory and the defense of France against Germany in World War II
without so much as a "thank you" to those who prevented them from having to learn German, and declare some sort of delusional victory. As Reuters points out, "In a turnout of 69.7 percent, many voters used the vote to punish Chirac and his government over France's economy and high unemployment. The 72-year-old leader promised to make changes but ignored calls from some in the "No" camp to step down." Surprise, surprise.For some, the defeat of the constitution in France is great news for Democracy in general and European democracy, in particular. In the Weekly Standard, Bill Kristol claims that this defeat offers opportunity for the proponents of democratic progress in Europe to stand up and make a difference, similar to the conservative overhaul in the recent American elections:
Europe deserves better than the political class and the political discourse (to use a European formulation) that it has been stuck with. In this respect, the leftists rallying in Paris against the constitution last Wednesday were right to insist that their "No" was "A hopeful No." This is a moment of hope--for the prospects for a strong, pro-American, pro-liberty, more or less free-market and free-trade, socially and morally reinvigorated Europe. In any case, as Le Figaro's Ivan Rioufol suggests, the referendum, whatever its outcome, has already had a "liberating effect." Rioufol explains, "It introduced freedom of speech into the French political debate. Until now, the political oligarchy and the media's politically correct group-think had silenced any critical mind. . . . The people's revolt and their demand for 'true talk' are sweeping away the old political scene and its political correctness."It remains to be seen just how far-reaching these effects will go and if they will actually be long-lasting, but certainly, it highlights the unrest that the French people feel under a failing governmental structure. Robert Spencer, of Dhimmi Watch, articulates many of the problems associated with the French Socialist government and why the people are becoming increasingly anti-establishment in their opinions of the ruling majority:
Behind the sturdy images of a forthright Europe on the road to a bright future lurks the shadow of a shameful antisemitism that has soaked into the very skin of European society. Economic stagnation and plus 10% unemployment eats away at France's elegant foundations. Life has become harsh, violence of all sorts is on the rise. The strong euro is no help to French wage earners. Social services are breaking down. Anti-war pro-Palestinian anti-American activism has not even brought hollow victories. Man can not live by bluster alone.However, these dreams of grandeur will never come through socialist forms of government. They simply do not work. France is a perfect example. Other socialist governments are following suit. I have a friend in Denmark who has severe back problems. Of course, this socialist government provides free, universal healthcare to all of its citizens at absolutely no cost to them. Wow, what a wonderful arrangement, huh? Except that in order to undergo his "free" surgery, he had to wait until the government said he could have it. In his case, that was over a year of dealing with excrutiating back pain. That was seven years ago and his back problems remained even after that wonderful medical attention he received. That is the state of socialist medicine.Democracy is leaking out of this tattered Europe. As national sovereignty is handed up to the higher echelons of the European Union, citizens lose their grip on the affairs of state. For all its brand name institutions --parliament, executive, commission, president and now secretary of state--the EU does not have a democratic infrastructure. It is recreating something like an old fashioned European empire where the ruling classes hobnob together in feasts and palaces, and dictate their will to the people. In the absence of grass roots power, commoners, with no constructive means of expression, resort to the sullen refusal to work, freedom to throw a monkey wrench into the system, go on strike on a holiday weekend, burn down an occasional factory. Some serious analysts of the Constitutional Treaty describe it as a blueprint for gridlock. Neither streamlined nor democratic, a far cry from a system of checks and balances, it institutionalizes ingrained European mistrust; every initiative will be vulnerable to blockage regardless of its scope or thrust. Good old fashioned power politics will be played on the ruins of this fictitious harmony. And France still seems to cherish dreams of grandeur.
Ironically, it is this socialism that many in France seem to be fighting to hold onto by issuing a no vote. Will a rejection of the EU constitution provide an opportunity for true democracy, free markets, new opportunities in European/American relations like Kristol optimistically hopes for? One can certainly hope so, yet it seems that the very reason many French citizens voted against the constitution was that it seemed to threaten their socialist ways as well as their sovereignty as a nation. It appears that these citizens want to see an increase in the socialism that already defines the country. Why would they possibly want to hold onto such weak structure? Perhaps one answer is that it is simply all they have ever known. As C.S. Lewis' said, "We are half-hearted creatures...like an ignorant child who wants to go on making mudpies in the slums because he cannot imagine what is meant by the offer of a holiday at the sea."
As a young boy, my mother often had to threaten to separate my friend and I when we would misbehave at inappropriate times. It was the first step in her regaining control and peace. One can hope that this type of move towards an effective Europe is what is happening. Perhaps we are witnessing a separation of old, obstructionist allies: "'This is the first time in 50 years that the French and Germans have diverged in Europe on a fundamental issue. Without this constitution, Europe is broken down politically,' said foreign minister Michel Barnier." [source: EUpolitix.com]
It is my hope and prayer that this "non" vote may provide opportunity for improvements to the European Union. I pray that more reasonable and noble voices will emerge to offer a more hopeful alternative for the people of Europe.
Update: For excellent and insightful commentary on the subject, check out today´s post by my friend, Peter Glover.
Labels: David C. Price



















Democracy is leaking out of this tattered Europe. As national sovereignty is handed up to the higher echelons of the European Union, citizens lose their grip on the affairs of state. For all its brand name institutions --parliament, executive, commission, president and now secretary of state--the EU does not have a democratic infrastructure. It is recreating something like an old fashioned European empire where the ruling classes hobnob together in feasts and palaces, and dictate their will to the people. In the absence of grass roots power, commoners, with no constructive means of expression, resort to the sullen refusal to work, freedom to throw a monkey wrench into the system, go on strike on a holiday weekend, burn down an occasional factory. Some serious analysts of the Constitutional Treaty describe it as a blueprint for gridlock. Neither streamlined nor democratic, a far cry from a system of checks and balances, it institutionalizes ingrained European mistrust; every initiative will be vulnerable to blockage regardless of its scope or thrust. Good old fashioned power politics will be played on the ruins of this fictitious harmony. And France still seems to cherish dreams of grandeur.




0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home